Image by TripAdvisor.com
*Vacation Mode is a for-profit site. It contains paid banner advertisements that are generated and managed by a third-party network. This site also includes relevant affiliate links (both in the content and on the sidebar) all of which we do our best to clearly mark as such.
Quick Summary
- Cultural Differences: Saint Lucia offers a diverse and authentic cultural experience with its French and British colonial history, while Aruba provides a modern and cosmopolitan atmosphere influenced by its Dutch heritage.
- Accommodation Options: Saint Lucia has a variety of lodging choices for all budgets, including luxurious resorts and budget-friendly guesthouses. Aruba is known for its luxurious resorts and all-inclusive options.
- Natural Beauty and Activities: Saint Lucia's lush natural beauty, including rainforests and scenic beaches, makes it ideal for adventure and outdoor activities. Aruba's attractions include clear turquoise waters, white sand beaches, and a vibrant nightlife, suitable for water sports enthusiasts.
- Price Comparison: Accommodations and food options vary in both destinations, with Saint Lucia offering budget to luxury stays and a diverse culinary scene. Aruba provides a mix of accommodations and is known for its fusion cuisine. Transportation is more convenient in Aruba due to its well-connected public system.
- Weather Differences: Saint Lucia has a tropical rainforest climate with high humidity and rainfall, while Aruba enjoys a tropical marine climate with low humidity and stable temperatures, making it less affected by tropical storms.
- Beaches and Scenic Views: Both destinations boast stunning beaches and natural landscapes. Saint Lucia's coastline features dramatic volcanic backdrops, whereas Aruba's beaches offer wide, sunbathing-friendly shores.
- Cultural Experiences: Explore Saint Lucia's rich history and natural wonders, including the iconic Pitons and local markets. Aruba's cultural attractions highlight its Dutch and colonial history through historical sites and local cuisine.
- Accommodation Based on Budget: Both Saint Lucia and Aruba cater to a wide range of budgets, from economical guesthouses to luxurious adult-only resorts, providing options for budget-conscious travelers and those seeking upscale experiences.
- Local Cuisine: Both islands offer unique culinary experiences, with Saint Lucia known for its seafood and local dishes like Green Fig and Saltfish, and Aruba featuring traditional dishes such as Keshi Yena that reflect its Dutch influence.
- Final Recommendation: The choice between Saint Lucia and Aruba depends on personal preferences for landscapes, activities, and cultural experiences. Saint Lucia is ideal for those seeking lush landscapes and adventure, while Aruba appeals to beach lovers and water sports enthusiasts.
Are you torn between choosing Saint Lucia or Aruba for your next vacation? Look no further! In this article, we will compare these two stunning destinations based on various factors such as price, natural beauty, lodging options, activities, weather, beaches, cultural experiences, accommodation choices, local cuisine, and more.
By the end, you will have a clearer idea of which destination suits your preferences best. So, let's dive in and discover whether Saint Lucia or Aruba is the perfect choice for your upcoming trip!
Key Takeaways:
- Saint Lucia offers a diverse and authentic cultural experience, while Aruba boasts a more modern and cosmopolitan atmosphere.
- Aruba is known for its luxurious resorts and all-inclusive options, while Saint Lucia has a variety of lodging choices to fit any budget.
- For those seeking adventure and outdoor activities, Saint Lucia's lush natural beauty and scenic beaches make it the ideal destination.
TOP 12 THINGS TO DO in SAINT LUCIA
Video by Matt James
Comparing Saint Lucia and Aruba: Which Destination is Right for You?
When deciding between Saint Lucia and Aruba for your next vacation, it's important to consider the unique offerings of each island destination.
In Saint Lucia, you will find lush rainforests, majestic Piton mountains, and stunning volcanic beaches. The island is known for its luxurious resorts, perfect for those seeking a romantic getaway or relaxation in a tropical paradise.
On the other hand, Aruba boasts crystal-clear turquoise waters, powdery white sand beaches, and a vibrant nightlife scene. Travelers looking for water sports, like snorkeling or windsurfing, will find Aruba to be a haven for aquatic adventures.
Both destinations offer rich cultural experiences, but Saint Lucia's French and British colonial history contrasts with Aruba's Dutch influence.
Price Comparison
Analyzing the price differences between Saint Lucia and Aruba can help budget-conscious travelers make an informed decision on their vacation destination.
In Saint Lucia, accommodation options range from boutique hotels nestled in lush tropical settings to budget-friendly guesthouses. On the other hand, Aruba offers a variety of accommodations, from all-inclusive resorts to cozy vacation rentals. Regarding food, Saint Lucia boasts a diverse culinary scene with local markets offering fresh produce, while Aruba is known for its fusion of Caribbean and international cuisines.
Transportation in Saint Lucia may include rental cars or public buses, which can be affordable but require planning. Aruba, on the other hand, has a well-connected public transportation system, making it convenient for travelers to explore the island at a reasonable cost.
Saint Lucia
In Saint Lucia, travelers can find a range of accommodation options from budget-friendly to luxurious, allowing visitors to tailor their stay based on their preferences and budget.
Aruba
Aruba offers a mix of accommodation choices, from upscale resorts to budget-friendly hotels, ensuring that visitors can find a stay that suits their financial preferences and travel needs.
Natural Beauty
Both Saint Lucia and Aruba boast stunning natural beauty, from lush greenery and white sand beaches to vibrant coral reefs and tropical landscapes.
While Saint Lucia is known for its dramatic twin peaks, the Pitons, rising majestically from the sea, Aruba captivates visitors with its iconic Divi Divi trees bending in the trade winds. Saint Lucia's lush rainforests provide a haven for diverse flora and fauna, while Aruba's arid desert landscapes showcase unique cacti and rock formations.
- Saint Lucia offers enchanting waterfalls like Toraille Falls and Diamond Falls, while Aruba's natural wonders include hidden gems like the Natural Pool and Arikok National Park.
- The contrast between Saint Lucia's black volcanic sand beaches like Anse Chastanet and the pristine white sands of Aruba's Eagle Beach adds to the allure of these Caribbean paradises.
Top Resorts in St. Lucia
Jade Mountain Resort
Jade Mountain Resort is perched high above the coastline, offering guests magnificent views of the Pitons and the Caribbean Sea. Known for its striking architectural design, the resort features rooms that open directly onto panoramic vistas, with no fourth wall, inviting the outside in. Guests can enjoy the ultimate in privacy and romance, with private infinity pools, gourmet dining, and personalized service, making it a perfect retreat for those looking to connect with nature in luxury.
Click here to get rates from Booking.com.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Sugar Beach, A Viceroy Resort
Sugar Beach, A Viceroy Resort, is beautifully situated between the Pitons, on a pristine white-sand beach. This resort seamlessly combines luxury with the natural environment, offering elegant villas and beachfront bungalows that come with private plunge pools. With its world-class rainforest spa, refined dining experiences, and a host of water sports and activities, Sugar Beach is an idyllic destination for relaxation and adventure.
Click here to get rates from Booking.com.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
The Ladera Resort
The Ladera Resort stands out with its unique position on a volcanic ridge, 1,000 feet above the sea, offering guests open-wall rooms that frame the stunning views of the Pitons and the ocean below. The resort's eco-friendly architecture, private plunge pools, and an award-winning farm-to-table restaurant cater to those seeking a romantic and intimate experience amidst the island's breathtaking scenery.
Cap Maison
Cap Maison, located on the northern tip of St. Lucia, combines Mediterranean elegance with Caribbean charm. Set atop a stunning cliff, the resort offers spacious suites and villas, some featuring private roof terraces and pools. Guests can dine at the acclaimed Cliff at Cap restaurant, relax on the secluded beach, or explore the waters aboard the resort's private yacht, making it a luxurious escape for those in search of beauty and tranquility.
Click here to get rates from Booking.com.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Marigot Bay Resort and Marina
Marigot Bay Resort and Marina overlooks one of the Caribbean's most beautiful and historic bays, offering luxury accommodations and a marina for yachting enthusiasts. The resort is surrounded by lush tropical gardens and provides a range of dining options and a luxurious spa. With its array of water sports and cultural experiences, Marigot Bay Resort is a haven for guests seeking both relaxation and adventure in a stunning setting.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Each of these resorts in St. Lucia offers a distinctive slice of paradise, catering to diverse preferences, whether one is in search of adventure, relaxation, or a romantic getaway amidst the island's natural splendor.
Top Resorts in Aruba
Aruba is home to a wide variety of resorts, each offering unique amenities, accommodations, and experiences that cater to different types of travelers. Here's a glimpse into some top resorts in Aruba, providing a mix of luxury, family-friendly options, and romantic escapes.
Amsterdam Manor Beach Resort
Nestled in the low-rise hotel zone across from Eagle Beach, this 72-room resort charms guests with its Dutch Colonial architecture and a range of studio or suite accommodations. It's pet-friendly, features a pool with a waterfall and a kids' pool, and offers all-inclusive access to two on-site restaurants, including a beachside option. Guests can also enjoy complimentary beach and pool lounge chairs, floats, bicycle rentals, and snorkeling gear.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Divi Aruba Phoenix Beach Resort
This resort is located along the turquoise waters of the Caribbean coast, offering studios and suites with up to three bedrooms, each featuring a kitchen and stunning sea views. Amenities include two pools and hot tubs, a children's pool, two open-air restaurants, a deli, and a variety of sports and family activities.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Divi Dutch Village Beach Resort
A family-friendly resort near Palm and Eagle beaches, offering king efficiencies, studio suites, or one- or two-bedroom suites, most with kitchens. Guests enjoy access to amenities across several Divi resorts, including multiple pools and hot tubs, free golf, and use of water sports equipment.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Tamarijn Aruba
This all-inclusive resort is located on Druif Beach and offers oceanfront views from every room. Guests can enjoy 10 dining options, four freshwater pools, a beachfront fitness center, water sports, and nightly entertainment. It's particularly noted for its connection to several other resorts, allowing access to a wide range of facilities.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Bucuti & Tara Beach Resort
An adults-only boutique resort on Eagle Beach, known for its romantic setting and eco-friendly accommodations. It features beachside dining, wellness programs, and various lovebird extras, ideal for couples seeking a serene escape.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Aruba Ocean Villas
This resort offers Aruba's only overwater bungalows in the fishermen's neighborhood of Savaneta. Villas are adorned with rich mahogany furniture, white linens, and Afro-Caribbean art, offering a luxurious yet rustic charm. The on-site restaurant exceeds typical hotel fare, making it a unique dining experience.
Click here to get rates from Agoda.com.
Each of these resorts provides a distinct experience, whether you're seeking a luxurious golf retreat, a family-friendly vacation, or a romantic getaway. They showcase the versatility and beauty of Aruba as a top destination for travelers seeking sun, sea, and sand. For more detailed information, consider exploring their official websites or visit Aruba's official tourism site.
Lodging Options
From luxurious resorts to charming boutique hotels and villa rentals, Saint Lucia and Aruba offer diverse lodging options to cater to every traveler's preferences and budget.
While Saint Lucia boasts world-class luxury resorts set against breathtaking backdrops of the Piton mountains, Aruba is known for its array of budget-friendly hotels located along the stunning white sandy beaches. Unique stay experiences on Saint Lucia include eco-friendly treehouse retreats deep in the rainforest, whereas Aruba offers cozy beachfront bungalows for a more intimate getaway.
Along with traditional accommodations, Saint Lucia features upscale all-inclusive resorts that pamper guests with gourmet dining and spa treatments, while Aruba's boutique hotels provide a personalized touch with local artwork and decor.
Activities and Popular Attractions
Saint Lucia and Aruba offer a wealth of activities and attractions for tourists, ranging from thrilling water sports like snorkeling and diving to cultural excursions and vibrant nightlife scenes.
While Saint Lucia boasts the iconic twin peaks of the Pitons and lush rainforests perfect for hiking adventures, Aruba features its famous natural wonders such as the Arikok National Park and stunning beaches like Eagle Beach. Visitors to Saint Lucia can also immerse themselves in the rich local culture through visits to historic sites like Pigeon Island National Landmark, while Aruba captivates travelers with its Dutch-influenced architecture and lively festivals.
Weather Differences
Understanding the weather patterns and seasonal variations in Saint Lucia and Aruba is essential for planning a trip that aligns with your preferred climate and weather conditions.
While both Saint Lucia and Aruba are known for their stunning beaches and picturesque landscapes, their weather characteristics differ significantly.
-
Saint Lucia, located in the eastern Caribbean, experiences a tropical rainforest climate with high humidity and abundant rainfall throughout the year. This climate also makes it prone to tropical storms and hurricanes, especially during the hurricane season from June to November.
-
On the other hand, Aruba, situated further south in the Caribbean Sea, falls under a tropical marine climate, characterized by relatively low humidity and a more consistent temperature range. The island rarely sees the effects of tropical storms or hurricanes, offering visitors a more stable and predictable weather pattern.
Beach Quality and Scenic Views
The beaches of Saint Lucia and Aruba offer pristine white sands, crystal-clear turquoise waters, and vibrant sea life, creating idyllic settings for beachgoers and water enthusiasts.
While Saint Lucia's beaches are known for their dramatic volcanic backdrops and lush greenery framing the coast, Aruba boasts a more arid landscape with cacti and divi-divi trees dotting the sandy shores.
- Saint Lucia's coastline features hidden coves and secluded bays, perfect for those seeking a peaceful escape.
- On the contrary, Aruba's beaches are wide open and expansive, ideal for sunbathing and beach activities.
Snorkeling in Saint Lucia offers glimpses of colorful coral reefs and majestic marine creatures like sea turtles and rays, while Aruba's underwater world is home to shipwrecks and diverse fish species that make for a captivating underwater adventure for snorkelers.
Saint Lucia
Saint Lucia's beaches are renowned for their powdery white sand, clear turquoise waters, and abundant sea life, making them ideal spots for snorkeling and beach relaxation.
Aruba
Aruba's beaches feature stunning white sands, pristine turquoise waters, and diverse marine life, providing visitors with exceptional snorkeling spots and picturesque coastal views.
Cultural Experiences and Excursions
Immerse yourself in the rich cultural heritage of Saint Lucia and Aruba through cultural excursions to historic sites, local markets, and culinary experiences that showcase the islands' unique traditions and flavors.
When visiting Saint Lucia, explore the iconic Pitons, two volcanic spires rising dramatically from the sea, offering breathtaking views and a UNESCO World Heritage site. Indulge in the local delicacies such as green fig and saltfish while mingling with friendly locals at the bustling Castries Market.
In contrast, Aruba invites you to discover its Dutch and colonial history through a visit to Fort Zoutman, the oldest structure on the island, and Aruban Cunucu houses that reflect the island's past. Enjoy a fusion of flavors at local eateries serving dishes like Keshi Yena and Funchi, providing insight into the island's diverse culinary influences.
Saint Lucia: The Culture
Saint Lucia's culture is a blend of rich history, vibrant traditions, and natural wonders, with attractions like the Butterfly Farm, colonial relics, and national parks showcasing the island's diverse heritage.
Aruba: The Culture
Aruba's culture is a tapestry of influences, from indigenous roots to colonial legacies, with attractions like the Butterfly Farm, colonial relics, and national parks offering glimpses into the island's diverse cultural tapestry.
Accommodation Choices Based on Budget
Whether you seek budget-friendly options or luxurious adult-only resorts with personalized service, Saint Lucia and Aruba cater to a diverse range of accommodation preferences for travelers of all tastes and budgets.
For budget-conscious travelers, Saint Lucia offers a variety of economical accommodations including guesthouses, hostels, and small hotels that provide basic amenities at affordable rates.
On the other hand, Aruba boasts upscale adult-only resorts that focus on creating a tranquil and exclusive atmosphere for couples and adults seeking a more sophisticated vacation experience.
Visitors to Saint Lucia can enjoy the charm of boutique hotels and inns scattered across the island, offering personalized services and unique cultural experiences.
In contrast, Aruba presents a selection of high-end resorts with tailored services such as private cabanas, spa treatments, and gastronomic delights, ideal for discerning travelers looking for a lavish escape.
Aruba
Aruba provides budget-friendly lodging options, luxurious adult-only resorts, and personalized service to cater to the varied preferences and financial considerations of travelers visiting the island.
Saint Lucia
In Saint Lucia, visitors can choose from budget-friendly accommodation options, upscale adult-only resorts, and stays with personalized service, ensuring a comfortable and tailored experience based on individual preferences and budget.
Comparing Local Cuisine
Indulge in the tantalizing flavors of local cuisine in Saint Lucia and Aruba, where dishes featuring fresh seafood, succulent lobster, and exotic ingredients like conch offer a culinary journey through the island's unique gastronomic delights.
In Saint Lucia, the national dish, Green Fig and Saltfish, is a staple featuring salted codfish sautéed with local seasoning and served with boiled green bananas or breadfruit. The island is also known for its flavorful pepper pot stew made with callaloo, okra, and other vegetables.
On the other hand, Aruba boasts of its traditional Keshi Yena, a savory dish of Gouda cheese stuffed with spiced meat that reflects the island's Dutch influence.
Saint Lucia: The Food
Saint Lucia's culinary scene is a celebration of seafood delights, with dishes like succulent lobster, fresh conch, and the vibrant Fish Fry showcasing the island's rich gastronomic heritage and flavors.
Aruba: The Food
Aruba's culinary landscape is a fusion of flavors, with seafood cuisine taking center stage, featuring delectable dishes like lobster, conch, and the vibrant Fish Fry that showcase the island's diverse culinary influences.
Which Destination is the Better Choice?
Deciding on the better destination between Saint Lucia and Aruba depends on your preferences for a tropical beach vacation, the allure of paradise, and considerations for safety and travel experiences that align with your expectations.
For those seeking a more lush, mountainous landscape with stunning volcanic peaks, Saint Lucia tends to be the ideal choice. The island is renowned for its dramatic topography, providing a backdrop that is not only visually breathtaking but also offers diverse opportunities for outdoor adventures like hiking and zip-lining.
In contrast, Aruba boasts a flatter terrain with gorgeous white sandy beaches that stretch for miles, making it a paradise for beach enthusiasts looking to soak up the sun and enjoy water sports like snorkeling and windsurfing.
Final Recommendations for Your Trip to Saint Lucia or Aruba
When planning your trip to Saint Lucia or Aruba, follow travel guidelines, adhere to health screening requirements, and stay informed about COVID safety measures and travel restrictions to ensure a smooth and enjoyable vacation experience.
Before embarking on your journey, check the entry requirements for Saint Lucia or Aruba to avoid any last-minute surprises.
Research local customs, transportation options, and popular attractions to make the most of your visit.
Consider booking accommodations that prioritize cleanliness and follow enhanced hygiene protocols for added peace of mind.
Pack essential items such as hand sanitizers, face masks, and disinfecting wipes to maintain personal hygiene throughout your trip.
Frequently Asked Questions
1. What are the main differences between St. Lucia and Aruba?
St. Lucia and Aruba are two very different Caribbean destinations. St. Lucia is known for its lush rainforests, volcanic landscapes, and romantic ambiance, while Aruba is known for its beautiful beaches, vibrant nightlife, and desert-like climate.
2. Which destination is better for a relaxing vacation?
If you're looking for a tranquil and laid-back vacation, St. Lucia may be the better choice. The island is less developed and has a slower pace of life compared to bustling Aruba.
3. Is one destination more budget-friendly than the other?
While both destinations offer a range of prices for accommodations and activities, Aruba tends to be slightly more expensive due to its popularity as a tourist destination. St. Lucia, on the other hand, has more affordable options for travelers on a budget.
4. Which island has better activities and attractions?
This depends on your personal preferences. St. Lucia is known for its outdoor adventures like hiking, zip lining, and snorkeling, while Aruba offers a variety of water sports, shopping, and cultural experiences.
5. Where should I go for a romantic getaway?
St. Lucia is a popular destination for couples seeking a romantic escape, thanks to its secluded resorts and breathtaking scenery. However, Aruba also has its fair share of romantic spots, such as secluded beaches and sunset cruises.
6. Is one destination safer than the other?
Both St. Lucia and Aruba have relatively low crime rates and are considered safe for tourists. However, as with any destination, it's important to use common sense and take precautions to ensure a safe trip.
